Accountability or Responsibility?

October 18, 2021

“There's no word for accountability in Finnish. Accountability is something that is left when responsibility has been subtracted.” Finnish Education Minister



“Accountability is done to you. It’s done by those who want to create blame. Responsibility is done by you. It’s voluntary. You can take as much [responsibility] as you want.” (Seth Godin)

In her article ‘5 Simple Ways to Teach your Son about Accountability,’ Cavalot (2020), captures that parenting moment with which we are all familiar:


“I only hit him because he called me an idiot.”


“I only called him an idiot because he broke my toy!”


Cavalot writes, ‘this game is not fun. It can go on forever. And no one ever wins.’ Undeniably, this scenario may render itself differently with daughters or be dependent upon the age of participants, but the essence of the blame game is unaltered: it’s about deflection of personal responsibility. Of course, this is not a skill, or a defect only associated with childhood, this practice re-emerges in adults too. Consequently, that is why the explicit modelling of responsibility needs to start with us as parents and teachers so that our children or students learn to accept not deflect the impact of their behaviour. More easily said than achieved, it would seem.


On topic, I read an online article a few weeks ago, titled ‘Players urged to ditch mates after Cameron Munster, Brandon Smith video emerges.’ What followed was a discussion of a post-end of season party involving Melbourne Storm players which hit social media and included advice of those ‘in the know’ as to how to avoid becoming the subject of public scrutiny.


Allegedly these two players were caught on film taking drugs. Within the article were phrases like, ‘You’ve got to be very careful who you surround yourself with,’ ‘…it’s always the other people around them that are getting them into trouble, not themselves,’ and, ‘Why take that risk? You’ve got a whole life after football to do whatever you like. You can go back into … society and do what you want, but while you’re a professional footballer, understand that there are people out there that are out to get you.’


When I read the article, I was propelled back to the scenario Cavalot (2020) had painted about her sons deflecting responsibility for their actions. This football article was redolent with deflection. Nowhere in the article was a suggestion that the choice to use drugs has consequences, irrespective of social status or employment type. Nowhere in the article was a suggestion that as public figures there is greater responsibility to act lawfully. Nowhere in the article was a suggestion of whether this was the right thing to do or the wrong thing to do. Focus was firmly on blaming the person who filmed and shared the incident – the person who should have said, apparently, ‘hey fellas you are doing the wrong thing.’ There is no doubt that illicit filming and sharing of that which occurs privately bears its own ethical transgressions but that is not the point of this reflection.


The undertone of the article seemed to represent the alleged offenders, those that sign a player code of conduct as part of their contractual obligations, as victims. Not only were they constructed as victims, but the blame was directed everywhere else. I failed to read accountability or responsibility for choice, anywhere. Rather, I read, do what you want but choose who you are with, when you do so. Further, if you get caught, it’s not your fault, it’s the fault of the people who you are with. Whether it takes a code of conduct to impel us in our lawful, moral or ethical choices – such codes exist. They are the written and unwritten laws that bind us to behave in particular ways. When we transgress, who is responsible? Michael Grose (2019) a prolific writer on parenting encapsulates this in such simple terms:


“When you muck up, you make up.” Goal: Responsibility 

“How will you fix this?” Goal: Restoring relationships

“You need to do what’s right, not what’s easy.” Goal: Integrity


Katherine Reynolds Lewis, author of ‘The Good News About Bad Behavior’, spent five years researching how kids mess up, and how [parents] can help them learn to handle those failures, which ultimately will set them up for success. She writes of the long path of parenting and the need to project into adulthood, to 20 years from now. Lewis asks, ‘in 20 years, will it matter more that your child got an A on a test, or learned the value of hard work?’ (cited in Struck, 2019). Cavalot (2020) reminds that facing mistakes or accepting disappointments instead of blaming others is a tough lesson for children and for parents – some never learn it. Sometimes we just learn how to deflect responsibility, how to blame others and how to avoid shame.


To whom and to what are we responsible? How do we learn it? First and foremost, we learn from our parents: the most powerful force on earth. Yet again, it’s starts with our example. Indeed, holding children responsible for their actions is one of the important ways we teach them so that they can become responsible adults. In this sense, it is more important to hold children responsible than adults.



Dr Linda Evans | Principal



References


Cavalot, B. (2021). 5 simple ways to teach your son about accountability ›


Grose, M. (2019). The language of independence building › 11 February 2019. Parenting Ideas.


Naghten, T. (2021). Players urged to ditch mates after Cameron Munster, Brandon Smith video emerges › 


Struck, J. (2019). Accountability in Parenting › March 4, 2019 









More News…

By Sarah Richardson January 31, 2025
Beginning. Starting. Commencing. What does beginning well actually look like? Sometimes when we expect a perfect start, we overlook the quiet power of simply showing up, the world is run by those who show up. Those people who never, ever ring the bell, those people who show up, even when it is hard to do so, especially when it is hard to do so. Brene Brown reminds us that “the willingness to show up changes us, it makes us a little braver each time we do.” In enacting bravery, it is important to start small if that’s what it takes. American Naval Admiral, William McRaven says this: “If you want to change the world, start off by making your bed. If you can’t do the little things right, then you will never do the big things right.” He believes in persistence. His mantra is this: don’t ever, ever ring the bell. He refers to the initial training for the United States of America Navy Sea, Air, and Land Teams the SEALS. Their initial training sees more than 80 percent of participants drop out. During this training, a brass bell hangs in the center of the room for all the students to see. If they find the work too hard. If they decide against becoming a SEAL. All they have to do to quit—is to ring the bell. Ring the bell and they no longer have to wake up at 5 o’clock. Ring the bell and they no longer have to complete freezing cold swims. Ring the bell and they no longer have to endure long runs carrying heavy weights, the obstacle courses, or to suffer the hardships of training. Just ring the bell and it’s all over. When exhausted SEAL candidates reach their breaking point, they haul themselves to the bell and ring it three times. The sound echoes through the training grounds and announces publicly that another candidate has “opted out.” All they have to do is ring the bell. Just ring the bell and the hard work stops. I wonder if Lilli Hamilton (Queensland cricketer and HEAT member) rang the bell when Cricket training no longer felt like it was fun, or if Alex Edwards (Australian Orienteering representative) opted out of orienteering because frankly, the distance was too far, or if Scarlett Sippell (Emus National Youth Touch Football Squad member) gave up because training was too tough …. what they would miss out on … When we opt out, even when it is hard, we also miss out on possibilities. There are so many opportunities at Fairholme to achieve one’s best - academically. In the Arts. In Sport. Opportunities to serve others. To be a good friend – a good person. But then again, if any of those things are too hard, all anyone has to do is – opt out. Say it’s too hard. Say they didn’t get selected in the right team. Say their teachers didn’t give them the right results. Say they weren’t given the right position. Text their parents and tell them that Fairholme is awful. All they have to do, is ring the bell. Yet, if we want to change the world, If we want to get the best out of this year at Fairholme, whatever that involves - never ever give up. Start small, aim big. Always show up. Don’t give up. Don’t ever, ever ring the bell. The most meaningful changes in life are often built in the times that no one sees, and, importantly, in the daily decision to simply show up, and to show up for others. When my daughter, Natalie was twenty-one, she began her teaching career at an Autism specialty school in Brixton, London. She would phone me often: for advice, for debriefing, for re-setting – her school was classified as being in Special Measures – it was on the brink of closure. Often, when she phoned to describe her day – to talk about the boys in her class, all aged 12 or 13, it went a little like this: “Today, Mashley threw a chair through a window because he didn’t like the activity we were doing. I had to break up a fight at lunch. Jerome pulled a knife on me. Three boys in my class have joined gangs.” I wanted to say: “Natalie: get another job. That one is too dangerous.” I wanted to fly her home from London, immediately. I had to stop the urge to board the next plane to London and rescue her. But my advice to her – was this: Show up. Keep showing up. No matter how you feel… Get up, dress up, show up: don’t give up. These kids need to know that someone cares enough to show up. After all, when we show up for others, we can affect the most profound of changes. I am always intrigued about who shows up here at Fairholme – especially at difficult times. In 2011 when floods ravaged Toowoomba and so much of Fairholme was flooded – staff showed up - in their holidays. They turned up to rip up carpets, move furniture, clean floors, and walls. Last year, in the sadness of Sess’ passing our community showed up, in droves, with deep compassion – importantly, our community showed up for one another. I think of 2024 Year 12s who showed up for others, after they had officially finished attending classes at and were preparing for or undertaking their external exams. Lizzy Kelly and Ciara Teahan showed up to play in the stage band, for the Year 11 Leaders Assembly, so that the group could perform at its best. Roma Aarons came to an Assembly in November to share a fabulous rendition of ‘Hotel California’. On a Sunday morning, early in December, graduated students Rachel Yap, Alana Callaghan, Amelia Ramia and Roma Aarons, showed up at Rosies to prepare food for Toowoomba people who don’t have easy access to basic necessities. After last year’s Interschool Athletics Carnival, Clare Hogan noticed staff picking up loads of lost property and carrying it into the Assembly Hall. She asked – Can I help? When we show up, especially when it is for others, especially when it’s hard, we learn a lot about ourselves and others. The students at the school where my daughter taught in Brixton, London – needed teachers to show up, they needed people to notice them, they needed interest, care, attention. They needed to know that they mattered. The willingness to show up changes us. It makes us a little braver each time, particularly when we show up for others. Show up. Keep showing up. Show up for others. And remember the advice of Naval Admiral, William McRaven … even when it’s hard, don’t ever, ever ring the bell. Begin well, continue well, finish well. Dr Linda Evans │Principal
By Sarah Richardson January 23, 2025
Fairholme College student Zoe Hurford is currently living the dream as part of an exchange program with the prestigious Rugby School in England. Her time abroad has been filled with memorable moments, cultural discoveries, and a deep appreciation for the warmth and support of the Rugby School community. ‘The Rugby School is incredible," Zoe shares enthusiastically. ‘My time here is disintegrating far too quickly, and there is so much more I want to do. Everyone is really welcoming and supportive—staff and students—and I cannot wait to make more memories with them all.’ Zoe recently had the chance to address the entire school during Chapel. In her speech, she highlighted Fairholme's rich history and shared some amusing observations about differences between Australia and the UK. Her witty recount of answering common questions about Australia had the audience in stitches. ‘Yes, I’ve seen a kangaroo. No, I don’t look under every chair in case something is sitting under it. Yes, there are spiders. No, I wouldn’t recommend trying to beat up a kangaroo,’ she joked, bringing a taste of Aussie humour to the English school. As part of her exchange, Zoe has embraced Rugby 7s as her chosen sport and is relishing every muddy moment on the pitch. ‘I am absolutely loving it, even though the pitches are always muddy—it’s too cold for them to dry. Returning to Bradley covered in mud has become a ritual. I’ve loved learning more about the game and am excited to improve my skills in the coming weeks.’ Adjusting to the academic life at Rugby School has been a challenge Zoe has embraced with determination. ‘My classes have been really good, more so now that I can actually find them,’ she laughs. ‘There’s a clear distinction between the work I’ve done and what they are doing here, but with my classmates' help, I’m getting fairly comfortable with the topics.’ No update about England would be complete without a mention of the weather. Zoe finds it surprisingly manageable. ‘It’s definitely cold, some days more than others, but it isn’t as cold as I was expecting. It doesn’t have Toowoomba’s harsh winds, so that makes a big difference,’ she says. However, the shorter daylight hours have been a noticeable change. ‘By 4 p.m., it’s dark, which makes doing afternoon activities a lot harder. And sadly, my farmer’s tan is slowly disappearing—a reality I’m still coming to terms with.’ As Zoe continues to immerse herself in this transformative experience, she remains grateful for the opportunity to represent Fairholme College and explore all that Rugby School has to offer.
By Sarah Richardson January 20, 2025
Fairholme College has officially launched its High-Performance Sport Program, an innovative initiative aimed at supporting student athletes in achieving their sporting and academic goals. The launch marked a significant milestone in the College’s ongoing commitment to empowering young women through both education and sport. Olympian and Fairholme Old Girl Tatum Stewart was the guest of honour, returning to her alma mater to help unveil the program. ‘It’s super exciting for these Fairholme students to have the exposure to this High-Performance Program. Looking back, if I had an opportunity like this, it definitely would have catapulted me even sooner into the high-performance sporting world,’ said Tatum. Casey Reynoldson, Fairholme’s newly appointed Head of High Performance, also sharing her vision for the program and her extensive experience in elite sports. Casey brings a wealth of expertise to the program, having studied Exercise Science, a Bachelor of Exercise Physiology, and completed a Masters of Secondary Teaching. She recently returned from the University of Yale, where she conducted a research project, adding further depth to her leadership of the program. ‘I’m incredibly excited to lead this new chapter for Fairholme’s athletes,’ said Casey. ‘The program is designed to help them enhance their athletic performance while providing them with the tools needed to balance the challenges of sport and academics.’ The program includes tailored strength and conditioning plans, load management strategies, recovery programs, fitness testing, and academic support. A highlight of the launch was the live demonstration of the program’s state-of-the-art timing gates, which will help athletes track and improve their performance. Fairholme has a proud legacy of athletic excellence, producing Olympians like Tatum Stewart, Dom Du Toit, Emilee Cherry, Cathy Freeman, and Dannielle Leisch. This year alone, over 130 Fairholme teams competed locally, with 450+ girls excelling in individual sports, 127 Darling Downs Representatives, and 21 Queensland athletes! This new program is set to propel Fairholme’s athletes to even greater success, reinforcing the College’s commitment to fostering the next generation of sporting champions.
All News
Share by: